If you love the natural look of cedar, you’ve probably run into two terms that sound almost identical: wood shingles and wood shakes. They’re often used interchangeably, but they differ in how they’re made, how they look, and how they hold up. In humid, storm-prone Tallahassee, those differences matter. Here’s what to know before you choose.
What Is the Difference Between Wood Shingles and Wood Shakes?
Wood shingles are sawn on both sides by machine, which gives them a smooth surface and a consistent, tapered thickness. They lie flat and tight, creating a clean, tailored appearance.
Wood shakes are split from the log, either by hand or with a machine, so at least one face stays rough and textured. They’re thicker and more irregular, giving the roof a rustic, dimensional look.
Appearance and Curb Appeal
Shingles suit traditional, Cape Cod, and cottage-style homes. Their uniform lines look polished, and they weather to a soft silver-gray.
Shakes deliver a bolder, storybook character that works well on craftsman, lodge, and rustic homes. Their uneven edges cast shadows that add depth. If you want a roof that looks handcrafted, shakes are hard to beat.
Durability and Lifespan
Both materials are often made from cedar, which resists decay better than many woods. Shakes are thicker, so in dry climates they can last longer than shingles. Tallahassee isn’t a dry climate, though. Humidity, heavy rain, and shade from our tree canopy encourage moss, mildew, and rot on any wood roof. Lifespan depends heavily on ventilation, installation quality, and regular upkeep, so expect real maintenance with either option.
Cost Comparison
Wood roofing costs more than standard asphalt shingles. Shakes typically cost more than wood shingles because the material is thicker and the installation is more labor-intensive. Your final price will depend on wood grade, roof size, pitch, and complexity. A free on-site estimate is the only reliable way to get real numbers.
Fire, Wind, and Code Considerations
Untreated wood is combustible, so many wood roofs are pressure-treated with fire retardant to earn a better fire rating. Wind is a bigger concern in Florida, where storm season tests every roof. Always confirm that your chosen product and installation method meet local building code, and check with your insurer, since some carriers have specific rules or surcharges for wood roofs.
Maintenance Needs
Wood roofs need more attention than most other materials. Plan on regular cleaning to remove debris, moss, and algae, along with periodic checks for cracked, split, or curling pieces. Keeping your gutters clear also helps, since trapped water speeds up rot along the roof edge. A scheduled roof inspection can catch small problems before they turn into leaks.
Are There Alternatives?
Many Tallahassee homeowners love the look of wood but want fewer maintenance headaches. Architectural shingle roofing offers dimensional texture and strong wind ratings at a lower cost, and it’s built for our humid climate. If your existing wood roof is near the end of its life, a roof replacement is a good time to compare materials side by side.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose wood shingles if you want a refined, uniform look and a slightly lower price. Choose wood shakes if you want maximum texture and rustic charm and you’re prepared for the upkeep. If low maintenance and storm performance top your list, it’s worth looking at other materials too.
Not sure which direction is right for your home? Call GutterHawk at 850-779-1081 or email [email protected] for a free estimate from Tallahassee’s roofing and gutter specialists.
Frequently Asked Questions
Shingles are machine-sawn for a smooth, uniform look. Shakes are split from the log, leaving a rough, textured surface and a thicker profile.
Shakes are thicker and can last longer in dry climates. In humid Florida, lifespan depends more on ventilation, installation quality, and maintenance than on the product type.
They can work, but humidity, rain, and shade promote moss and rot, so they need regular cleaning and inspection. Many homeowners compare them with architectural shingles or metal.
Usually, yes. Shakes require more material and more labor to install. A free estimate will give you accurate pricing for your roof.
At least once a year, and after major storms. Early detection of cracked, split, or lifting pieces helps prevent leaks and costly repairs.