GutterHawk Roofing and Gutter Specialists

Felt Vs. Synthetic Underlayment: What Is the Difference?

Felt Vs. Synthetic Underlayment: What Is the Difference?

In roofing underlayment, felt offers tear resistance but is vulnerable to moisture. Synthetic surpasses moisture protection and tearing durability with better longevity. Felt is cost-effective upfront, while synthetic proves superior in the long run despite the higher material costs. Synthetic is lighter and more flexible for easier installation, impacting overall ease. Moisture resistance is essential; felt can degrade over time, but synthetic excels. Understanding these subtleties will guide your choice of the ideal underlayment. For professional guidance and installation, consulting a Tallahassee roofer can ensure you select and install the best underlayment for your needs.

Durability Comparison

When evaluating the durability of felt and synthetic underlayment, it is important to assess their resistance to tearing, moisture intrusion, and long-term performance. Felt underlayment, made from organic materials such as cellulose or bitumen-saturated paper, offers good tear resistance but is more prone to moisture damage over time. On the other hand, synthetic underlayment, composed of polyethylene or polypropylene, provides superior moisture protection and durability against tearing. 

When comparing longevity, synthetic underlayment tends to outperform felt underlayment due to its inherent material differences. The artificial materials used in underlayment production offer increased strength and resilience, ensuring better long-term performance on roofs subjected to varying weather conditions.

Cost Analysis

How do the cost considerations for felt and synthetic underlayment compare with the long-term value for roofing projects? When evaluating the cost-effectiveness of these materials, it is essential to take into account their initial price, installation costs, and longevity. Felt underlayment is traditionally more cost-effective upfront compared to synthetic underlayment. However, when looking at the long-term value, synthetic underlayment may prove to be more cost-effective due to its superior durability and lifespan. Synthetic underlayment typically has a higher material cost but can offer savings in the long run by reducing the need for premature replacements and repairs. Therefore, a thorough material comparison is essential to determine the most cost-effective option for roofing projects in the long term.

Installation Ease Evaluation

Considering the complexities of installation processes, evaluating installation ease between felt and synthetic underlayment necessitates thoroughly examining their respective properties and application methods. The importance of use plays a significant role in determining the suitability of underlayment for a roofing project. Felt underlayment, traditionally made from natural materials like wood cellulose or recycled paper, can be heavier and more cumbersome to handle during installation compared to synthetic options. Synthetic underlayment, often constructed from polypropylene or polyester, tends to be lighter and more flexible, making it easier to maneuver and install on the roof. 

These material differences directly impact the ease of use, affecting the efficiency and speed at which the underlayment can be laid down, ultimately influencing the overall installation process.

Performance Assessment

In evaluating the performance of felt and synthetic underlayment, we will assess their durability and weather resistance under varying conditions. Moisture resistance is a critical aspect to take into account, as both materials must protect the roof from water infiltration. Felt underlayment, made from organic materials, may degrade over time when exposed to moisture, potentially compromising its effectiveness. On the other hand, synthetic underlayment, typically composed of materials like polypropylene or polyester, often offers superior moisture resistance, ensuring long-term protection for the roof structure. Moreover, thermal properties play a role in the underlayment’s performance. Synthetic underlayment tends to have better thermal properties, providing enhanced insulation for the building. Understanding these factors is essential for selecting the most suitable underlayment for a roofing project.

Other Roofing Tips:

Ready To Get Started?

Working With Us Is Easy


Request Your Quote

Getting the process started is easy!  Simply fill out our quick form or call us at 850-656-4295.  One of our friendly staff members will get in touch to finalize the details.


We Work On Your Estimate

One of our expert estimators will get to to work analyzing your job and crafting a proposal.  Of course, we’re here to answer any questions you may have.


GutterHawk Gets To Work!

You can rest assured that the most capable professionals using the best quality materials are diligently working on your home.  It’s why Tallahassee trusts GutterHawk!

Contact Us

Contact Us

Have questions about your roof?  Do you need information on gutter maintenance plans? No matter the question, GutterHawk is here to help!

Scroll to Top